Topaz Bridge Blog

September 10, 2009
Wrapping it Up: Driving Business Value by Leveraging “ESS 2.0″ (Part 7 of 7)
 In our final installment, I will summarize our findings and present a total comprehensive view of the ABC Corporation’s three year total cost of ownership model comparing ESS 1.0 to ESS 2.0, the associated net present value of those dollar savings, and a review of the cumulative annual ROI associated with deploying a unified portal that leverages ESS 2.0 HCM Self Service delivery.

Unlocking Employee & Manager (ESS/MSS) Productivity with ESS 2.0
In our second blog posting, I showed how to calculate the total transactions and ultimate productivity gains leveraging some example variables such as time savings associated with various transaction types; frequency of example transactions; estimated average salary and overhead for the majority of our employees. With our total ESS transactions for ABC Company running close to 3.5M transactions per year I estimated the time savings and then mapped the time savings to the average cost per employee. In terms of employee productivity alone a conservative estimate of nearly $1M per year in savings for ABC Corporation may be associated with ESS 2.0 oriented self service delivery for HCM.

The third blog posting dealt with estimated manager savings and again using example variables such as time savings associated with various transaction types; frequency of example transactions; estimated average salary and overhead for the majority of our managers – I was able to derive ESS 2.0 manager savings. In terms of manager productivity alone an estimate of nearly $2M per year in savings for ABC Corporation may be realized with ESS 2.0 oriented self service delivery for HCM.

As illustrated in figure 1, over $9M in three year total savings exists between an ESS 1.0 and an ESS 2.0 deployment.

Figure 1 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 (Employee & Manager) Productivity Savings Estimates $9,092,534

Figure 1 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 (Employee & Manager) Productivity Savings Estimates $9,092,534

Saving Shared Services Support Costs with ESS 2.0
In blog posting #4, I estimated shared service savings associated with ESS/MSS transactions at ABC Corporation leveraging variables such as # of employees – 30K; time associated with various transaction types; frequency of example transactions; estimated average salary and overhead for the majority of our employees; estimated average salary and overhead for the support personnel; and percentages of transactions requiring support in the ESS 1.0 environment as compared to the ESS 2.0 environment. In terms of shared services savings for employee and manager self service transaction of all frequencies, just over $1.7M per year in estimated savings for ABC Corporation may be realized with ESS 2.0 self service delivery for HCM.

Figure 2 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Shared Services Savings Estimates $5,354,648

Figure 2 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Shared Services Savings Estimates $5,354,648

End User Training with ESS 2.0
Now in blog posting #5, I modeled training savings associated with ESS/MSS transactions at ABC Corporation using variables such as estimated average salary and overhead for training personnel; and percentages of transactions requiring training in the ESS 1.0 environment as compared to the ESS 2.0 environment).  In terms of training savings for employee and manager self service transaction of all frequencies, the conservative estimate is over $1.1M per year in savings (or $3.4M for total of 3 years - see figure 3) for ABC Corporation associated with ESS 2.0 self service delivery for HCM.

Figure 3 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Training Savings Estimate $3,484,440

Figure 3 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Training Savings Estimate $3,484,440

Realizing Developer and Deployment Savings with ESS 2.0
As discussed, the option to leverage an off-the-shelf solution significantly accelerates business value while avoiding the commitment to long-term maintenance and support obligations for internal solutions.  Modeling this information using development metrics such as total number of forms, the number of countries involved in the deployment, the costs for in-house and third party developers and support professionals, conservative estimates of nearly $1M worth of savings over the initial three year deployment period for ABC Corporation may be realized with ESS 2.0 self service delivery for HCM.

igure 4 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Development, Deployment & Support Savings Estimate $1,385,721

Figure 4 Total Three Year ESS 2.0 Development, Deployment & Support Savings Estimate $1,385,721

 
Netting it out… ESS 2.0 Drives Business Value Now!
Figure 5 illustrates that ABC Corporation will be able to recoup their investment in less than 6 months based on these gains and savings.  
Figure 5  ESS 2.0 Cumulative Return on Investment for ABC Corporation

Figure 5 ESS 2.0 Cumulative Return on Investment for ABC Corporation

Additionally, the total ESS 1.0 three year total cost of ownership for ABC Corporation is $72,719,186 as compared to the total ESS 2.0 three year total cost of ownership $53,401,843 representing a net three year savings of $19,317,343 minus the initial software license investment and year 2/3 maintenance or $2,737,500.  The total net present value of ESS 2.0 three year savings is $13,652,294 using an annual NPV discount of 10%. 
The combination of SAP® ERP/HCM and Microsoft® Office SharePoint® Server Line of Business applications has the potential to transform and unify a workforce by integrating - in a single portal - key corporate business processes (structured data) with relevant and process/role-driven unstructured content.  The business value in terms of 3 year TCO savings associated with unifying unstructured, contextually rich and role driven information with line of business operationally structured data results in a rapid-fire return on investment (ROI). 
As I have been discussing in this blog series on HCM Self Service Business Value, the ROI is measured by the significant productivity gains and cost savings in terms of employee/manager productivity, shared services savings, training, deployment and development savings.  For a final illustration of this three year total cost of savings please note the following graphic generated using the Topaz Bridge Value Calculator (see Figure 6 below).  Please note the net annual savings, the various components of TCO and the initial investment figures.  For further information about how we can help model your business value for ESS/MSS Self Service delivery, just ping me at jim.ofarrell@topazbridge.com.
Figure 6 Topaz Bridge Interactive ESS 2.0 Business Value Calculator

Figure 6 Topaz Bridge Interactive ESS 2.0 Business Value Calculator

 

 


No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.